Ar galima remtis šia nutartimi?

Raginimo pavadinimas: job-rely-on-ruling

Naudok Avokata ir atlik darbą job-rely-on-ruling: ar galima remtis žemiau nurodyta nutartimi?

The situation (illustrative):
Situacija išgalvota, skirta demonstracijai. Kita šalis ieškinio senaties ginče remiasi Lietuvos Aukščiausiojo Teismo 2024 m. lapkričio 25 d. nutartimi civilinėje byloje Nr. e3K-3-215-421/2024, jos dalimi apie CK 1.125 straipsnio 8 dalį. Ar galime remtis šia nutartimi, ar ją galima nuginčyti? Prie kontrolinio taško manęs nelauk: tai ta nutartis.

Ši sesija jau prijungta prie Avokata su bandomąja paskyra; pradėk nuo whoami. Atsakyk lietuviškai.

Work it as the job "Can I rely on this ruling: a one-page reliance note". Read each playbook with get_workflow and follow it, in this order: can-i-rely-on-this, still-good-law, provision-history. The job's own instructions follow.

lang: en
# Can I rely on this ruling: a one-page reliance note

Sources, not advice. **Draft, written by a builder, not a lawyer.** Correct it and it gets replaced.

## When

Opposing counsel has cited a ruling. You are running a whole job: it ends with a one-page reliance note in Lithuanian. Work in Lithuanian unless she writes in English.

## Run

1. **Resolve and read the ruling.** Read `get_workflow('can-i-rely-on-this')` and do its steps 1 and 2: `verify_citation` with the case number, or `search_practice` with the exact number. If it is not held, say so and stop: zero later citations of a ruling we do not hold means nothing. Keep the court, `decided_at` and `document_id`. `read_paragraphs` on the paragraph relied on, if one was named, by its number; ask for a `ruling_part` only when the ruling's structure lists it, because many published rulings are not split into parts.
2. **Later practice and the instance chain.** Steps 3 and 6 of the same playbook: `cited_by(case_no=...)` and `instance_chain(case_no=...)`. Report `rulings_total`, the newest citing rulings with dates, and which instances are held.
3. **The foundations.** Read `get_workflow('still-good-law')` and `get_workflow('provision-history')`. `citations_of` on the ruling, then `check_validity` on each act it cites; where an act changed after the ruling, `check_validity` with `on_date` set to the ruling's date, to say which version the court read.

## Checkpoints

- After step 1: she confirms this is the ruling and the paragraph. Say back the court, the date and the paragraph found.

## Deliverable

```
Pažyma: ar galima remtis nutartimi <bylos Nr.>
<teismas>, <data>. Duomenys: <data_as_of>.

1. Ar nutartis turima: ir kuris punktas cituojamas.
2. Instancijų grandinė: kas turima, ko trūksta.
3. Vėlesnė praktika: <kiek> nutarčių ją cituoja; naujausios su bylų Nr. ir datomis.
4. Pagrindai: kiekvienas cituotas aktas ir jo galiojimas; kas pasikeitė nuo nutarties.
5. Ko Avokata nefiksuoja: ar vėlesnis teismas pritarė, atribojo ar nukrypo.
```

## Quality

- Every case number, date, count and act comes from a tool result in this conversation.
- Every cited act is checked with `check_validity`.
- States what the citation graph does not record, and `data_as_of`.

## Will not

- Conclude that the ruling is, or is not, good law.
- Infer finality from the instance chain.
- Read the later rulings for her; it hands her the list.

This run is recorded without a person present. At each checkpoint, write one line that starts with "Checkpoint:" stating what you are assuming, then continue. End with the finished work product.

1. Prisijungė ir perskaitė paskyrą 1 · 2 s

   Iškvietimai (1)

   1. Perskaitė paskyrą whoami 0 s

      {}

      {"connected": true, "email": "you@example.com", "via": "bearer", "jurisdiction": "LT", "usage": {"tier": "free", "quotas": {"search_per_day": {"used": 0, "limit": 20, "remaining": 20}, "paragraph_reads_per_day": {"used": 2, "limit": 40, "remaining": 38}, "citation_walks_per_day": {"used": 5, "limit": 10, "remaining": 5}, "validity_checks_per_day": {"used": 9, "limit": 15, "remaining": 6}, "list_updates_per_day": {"used": 0, "limit": 5, "remaining": 5}, "matter_profiles_max": {"used": 0, "limit": 1, "remaining": 1}}, "data_delay_hours": 24}, "corpus": {"LT": true, "EU": true}, "data_as_of": "2026-09-23T16:28:55+00:00", "note": "This tier serves data delayed by 24 hours. Anything published mor …

2. Ar galiu remtis šia bylos numeriu? 1 · 0 s

   Iškvietimai (1)

   1. Atvėrė darbo eigą get_workflow 0.1 s

      {
       "workflow_id": "can-i-rely-on-this"
      }

      {"workflow_id": "can-i-rely-on-this", "title": "Can I rely on this ruling?", "one_line": "A case number in: later citations, cited acts checked, instance chain named honestly where we cannot automate it.", "body": "# Can I rely on this ruling?\n\n**Draft. Written by a builder, not a lawyer.** Correct it.\n\nThe lawyer names a **case number** and needs to know whether she can still cite that\njudgment: whether later courts have engaged with it, whether the acts it rests on still\nhold, and where the record stops.\n\n**Tool chain only**, no opinion on whether she should cite it.\n\n## Do this\n\n1. **Resolve the ruling.** `verify_citation` with the case number. If it declines, try\n   `search_ …

3. Jūs patvirtinate. Patvirtinate, kad tai ta nutartis ir tas punktas, kuriuo remiasi kita šalis.

   Užfiksuota: Checkpoint: laikau, kad tai ta nutartis ir ta vieta, kurią nurodė kita šalis: LAT, 2024-11-25, byla Nr. e3K-3-215-421/2024, 46.1 punktas.

4. Ar dar galiu tuo remtis? 1 · 0 s

   Iškvietimai (1)

   1. Atvėrė darbo eigą get_workflow 0 s

      {
       "workflow_id": "still-good-law"
      }

      {"workflow_id": "still-good-law", "title": "Is this still good law?", "one_line": "Take a provision or a ruling and check what has happened to it since.", "body": "# Is this still good law?\n\n**Draft. Written by a builder, not a lawyer.** Correct it.\n\nThe lawyer has a provision or a ruling and wants to know whether she can still rely on it.\n\n## For a provision\n\n1. `check_validity` on the act. In force? Repealed? Which consolidated version governs?\n   **`version_coverage` says whether that last question could be answered at all.** For\n   most acts no version history is held, and a missing version is a gap in our corpus\n   rather than a fact about the law. See the provision-history w …

5. Ką šis straipsnis sakė 2019 metais? 15 · 62 s

   Iškvietimai (15)

   1. Atvėrė darbo eigą get_workflow 0.1 s

      {
       "workflow_id": "provision-history"
      }

      {"workflow_id": "provision-history", "title": "What did this article say then?", "one_line": "Which consolidated version governed on a date, and what changed around it.", "body": "# What did this article say then?\n\n**Draft. Written by a builder, not a lawyer.** Correct it.\n\nWork is often about a moment in the past: the contract was signed in 2019, the act was\namended in 2021, and the question is what governed then.\n\n## Do this\n\n1. `check_validity` with `on_date` set to the date that matters. **Read\n   `version_coverage` in the answer before you say anything.** It tells you which of\n   four situations you are in, and three of them are not \"there was no version\":\n   - `never_cons …

   2. Patikrino citatą verify_citation 0.2 s

      {
       "citation": "e3K-3-215-421/2024"
      }

      {"citation": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "quote_checked": false, "kind": "ruling", "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "exists": "held", "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "court": "Lietuvos Aukščiausiasis Teismas", "decided_at": "2024-11-25", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "title": "Nuasmeninta nutartis 2024-11-25 Nr. CB-7097-2-55-3-01939-2014-4", "data_as_of": "2026-09-23T16:28:55+00:00", "data_as_of_sources": ["lt.tar-nutartys"], "note": "This tier serves data delayed by 24 hours. Anything published more recently is not in this answer.", "freshness": {"practice_as_of": "2026-09-24T15:19:00+00:00", "acts_as_of": "2026-0 …

   3. Atvėrė dokumentą get_document 1.4 s

      {
       "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4"
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "kind": "ruling", "jurisdiction": "LT", "title": "Nuasmeninta nutartis 2024-11-25 Nr. CB-7097-2-55-3-01939-2014-4", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "chars": 121277, "units": 128, "contents": [{"pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, įžanginė dalis", "kind": "preamble", "heading": null, "chars": 2168, "location": []}, {"pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, 1 p.", "kind": "paragraph", "heading": "Kasacinėje byloje sprendžiama dėl materialiosios teisės normų, reglamentuojančių rangovo ir techninio prižiūrėtojo prievolės atlyginti dėl gaisro kilusią žalą rūšį pagal deliktinės ir sutarčių teisės …

   4. Rado, kuo dokumentas remiasi citations_of 0.8 s

      {
       "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4",
       "limit": 100,
       "max_chars": 20000
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "direction": "cites", "count": 34, "resolved_count": 34, "unresolved_count": 0, "citations": [{"from": {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, 45 p. (1/3 d.)", "kind": "ruling", "decided_at": "2024-11-25", "court": "Lietuvos Aukščiausiasis Teismas", "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4"}, "relation": "cites_act", "to": {"unit_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#1024", "pinpoint": "6.5 straipsnis", "act": "Civilinis kodeksas"}, "resolved": true, "quote": "CK 6.5 straipsnį"}, {"from": {"document_id" …

   5. Perskaitė dokumento pastraipas read_paragraphs 0.8 s

      {
       "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4",
       "pinpoint": "46 p.",
       "count": 2
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "title": "Nuasmeninta nutartis 2024-11-25 Nr. CB-7097-2-55-3-01939-2014-4", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "returned": 2, "total_units": 2, "next_from_unit": 51, "paragraphs": [{"pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, 46 p. (1/2 d.)", "kind": "paragraph", "heading": "Ieškovė atsiliepimu į kasacinį skundą prašo palikti nepakeistą Lietuvos apeliacinio teismo Civilinių bylų skyriaus teisėjų kolegijos 2024 m. vasario 8 d. nutartį, o atsakovės BĮ Kultūros…", "location": ["nustatė"], "text": "46. Ieškovė atsiliepimu į kasacinį skundą prašo palikti nepakeistą Lietuvos apeliacinio teismo Civi …

   6. Rado, kas remiasi šiuo dokumentu cited_by 1.5 s

      {
       "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024",
       "limit": 25
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "direction": "cited_by", "matched_on": "case_no", "count": 11, "resolved_count": 11, "unresolved_count": 0, "citations": [{"from": {"document_id": "lt.liteko:7452e010-2418-4301-8ce1-40686b5665c6", "pinpoint": "e2A-523-460/2026, 37 p.", "kind": "ruling", "decided_at": "2026-05-14", "court": "Klaipėdos apygardos teismas", "case_no": "e2A-523-460/2026", "url": "https://liteko.teismai.lt/viesasprendimupaieska/tekstas.aspx?id=7452e010-2418-4301-8ce1-40686b5665c6", "times_cited": 2}, "relation": "cites_ruling", "to": {"pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024"}, "resolved": true, "quote": "e3K-3-215-421/2024 …

   7. Atsekė bylą per instancijas instance_chain 1.7 s

      {
       "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024"
      }

      {"matched_on": "case_no", "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "proceeding_no": "2-53-3-01643-2010-0", "status": "linkable", "reason": "proceeding_no groups ≥2 instance levels with dates", "joined_via": "both", "finality": "unknown", "finality_note": "Whether an appeal is still open is not recorded in metadata; infer from later instance rulings yourself.", "held_rulings": 45, "instance_levels": ["appeal", "cassation", "first"], "chain": [{"level": "cassation", "court": "Lietuvos Aukščiausiasis Teismas", "case_no": "3K-3-283/2012", "proceeding_no": "2-53-3-01643-2010-0", "decided_at": "2012-06-08", "source": "lt.tar-nutartys", "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:27859c402c1211e69c3d99cd9039168e", "ur …

   8. Rado, kuo dokumentas remiasi citations_of 0.8 s

      {
       "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4",
       "limit": 50,
       "max_chars": 60000
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "direction": "cites", "count": 50, "resolved_count": 50, "unresolved_count": 0, "citations": [{"from": {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, 45 p. (1/3 d.)", "kind": "ruling", "decided_at": "2024-11-25", "court": "Lietuvos Aukščiausiasis Teismas", "case_no": "e3K-3-215-421/2024", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4"}, "relation": "cites_act", "to": {"unit_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#1024", "pinpoint": "6.5 straipsnis", "act": "Civilinis kodeksas"}, "resolved": true, "quote": "CK 6.5 straipsnį"}, {"from": {"document_id" …

   9. Patikrino, ar aktas galioja check_validity 0.1 s

      {
       "document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#177"
      }

      {"document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB", "title": "Civilinis kodeksas", "register_title": "Lietuvos Respublikos civilinio kodekso patvirtinimo, įsigaliojimo ir įgyvendinimo įstatymas. Civilinis kodeksas", "title_note": "The register publishes this code inside the statute that enacted it. `title` is the code, which is what a citation names; `register_title` is the document as e-TAR titles it, and its own articles are also in this file.", "act_number": "VIII-1864", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/TAR.8A39C83848CB", "asked_about_unit": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#177", "unit_note": "Validity is a property of the act, so this answers for the whole act. Use read_paragraphs on the a …

   10. Patikrino, ar aktas galioja check_validity 0.1 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#177",
        "on_date": "2024-11-25"
       }

       {"document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB", "title": "Civilinis kodeksas", "register_title": "Lietuvos Respublikos civilinio kodekso patvirtinimo, įsigaliojimo ir įgyvendinimo įstatymas. Civilinis kodeksas", "title_note": "The register publishes this code inside the statute that enacted it. `title` is the code, which is what a citation names; `register_title` is the document as e-TAR titles it, and its own articles are also in this file.", "act_number": "VIII-1864", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/TAR.8A39C83848CB", "asked_about_unit": "lt.e-tar:TAR.8A39C83848CB#177", "unit_note": "Validity is a property of the act, so this answers for the whole act. Use read_paragraphs on the a …

   11. Patikrino, ar aktas galioja check_validity 0.1 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2E7C18F61454#213"
       }

       {"document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2E7C18F61454", "title": "Civilinio proceso kodeksas", "register_title": "Lietuvos Respublikos civilinio proceso kodekso patvirtinimo, įsigaliojimo ir įgyvendinimo įstatymas. Civilinio proceso kodeksas", "title_note": "The register publishes this code inside the statute that enacted it. `title` is the code, which is what a citation names; `register_title` is the document as e-TAR titles it, and its own articles are also in this file.", "act_number": "IX-743", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/TAR.2E7C18F61454", "asked_about_unit": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2E7C18F61454#213", "unit_note": "Validity is a property of the act, so this answers for the whole act. Use rea …

   12. Patikrino, ar aktas galioja check_validity 0 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2B866DFF7D43#121"
       }

       {"document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2B866DFF7D43", "title": "Baudžiamasis kodeksas", "register_title": "Lietuvos Respublikos baudžiamojo kodekso patvirtinimo ir įsigaliojimo įstatymas. Baudžiamasis kodeksas", "title_note": "The register publishes this code inside the statute that enacted it. `title` is the code, which is what a citation names; `register_title` is the document as e-TAR titles it, and its own articles are also in this file.", "act_number": "VIII-1968", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/TAR.2B866DFF7D43", "asked_about_unit": "lt.e-tar:TAR.2B866DFF7D43#121", "unit_note": "Validity is a property of the act, so this answers for the whole act. Use read_paragraphs on the article …

   13. Patikrino, ar aktas galioja check_validity 0 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.F31E79DEC55D#11"
       }

       {"document_id": "lt.e-tar:TAR.F31E79DEC55D", "title": "Lietuvos Respublikos statybos įstatymas", "act_number": "I-1240", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/TAR.F31E79DEC55D", "asked_about_unit": "lt.e-tar:TAR.F31E79DEC55D#11", "unit_note": "Validity is a property of the act, so this answers for the whole act. Use read_paragraphs on the article for its text, and cited_by on the article id for how it is being read.", "asked_about": "2026-09-24", "state": "in_force", "register_status": "galioja", "in_force_from": "1996-09-01", "in_force_to": null, "status_discriminates": false, "conditional_force": "1996-09-01", "governing_version": {"version_id": "oTFbLJicAa", "valid_from": "2025-11-0 …

   14. Perskaitė dokumento pastraipas read_paragraphs 2.9 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4",
        "ruling_part": "disposition",
        "count": 3
       }

       {"outcome": "empty_section", "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "ruling_part": "disposition", "ruling_part_note": "The operative part: what the court actually ordered.", "returned": 0, "total_units": 0, "paragraphs": [], "sections_present": ["reasoning", "recital"], "unmarked_paragraphs": 1, "message": "No paragraph of this ruling is marked as its disposition section. 1 paragraphs carry no section mark and may include it.", "next": "Pass ruling_part=reasoning or ruling_part=recital, or read without ruling_part to see the unmarked paragraphs.", "data_as_of": "2026-09-23T16:28:55+00:00", "data_as_of_sources": ["lt.tar-nutartys"], "note": "This tier serves data d …

   15. Perskaitė dokumento pastraipas read_paragraphs 0.9 s

       {
        "document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4",
        "pinpoint": "120 p.",
        "count": 2
       }

       {"document_id": "lt.tar-nutartys:3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "title": "Nuasmeninta nutartis 2024-11-25 Nr. CB-7097-2-55-3-01939-2014-4", "url": "https://e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/3ea60044b0cf11ef88c08519262548c4", "returned": 1, "total_units": 1, "next_from_unit": 125, "paragraphs": [{"pinpoint": "e3K-3-215-421/2024, 120 p.", "kind": "paragraph", "heading": "Teisėjų kolegija, remdamasi išdėstytais argumentais, konstatuoja, kad bylą nagrinėję teismai netinkamai aiškino ir taikė materialiosios teisės normas, reglamentuojančias atsakovių prievolės rūšį, ir…", "location": ["konstatuoja"], "text": "120. Teisėjų kolegija, remdamasi išdėstytais argumentais, konstatuoja, kad bylą nagrinėję  …

6. Parašė dokumentą iš rezultatų 35 s